Rare case of posterior hip dislocation caused by low-energy trauma in a boy in early adolescence: acute and long-term management–review of the literature

  1. Magdalena Kwiatkowska 1 , 2,
  2. Kyle Coombes 1 and
  3. Amir Siddique 2
  1. 1 American University of the Caribbean School of Medicine BV, Cupecoy, Sint Maarten (Dutch part)
  2. 2 Department of Orthopedics, Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda, Ireland
  1. Correspondence to Kyle Coombes; KyleCoombes@students.aucmed.edu

Publication history

Accepted:10 Aug 2022
First published:25 Aug 2022
Online issue publication:25 Aug 2022

Case reports

Case reports are not necessarily evidence-based in the same way that the other content on BMJ Best Practice is. They should not be relied on to guide clinical practice. Please check the date of publication.

Abstract

The incidence of hip dislocations in teenagers caused by low-velocity trauma is a relatively rare finding and constitutes a true orthopaedic emergency. Prompt reduction is recommended to avoid long-term complications. On average, the non-weight-bearing period ranges from 4 to 6 weeks. Follow-up with radiographic imaging is necessary to evaluate for hip pathologies over time. In this paper, we will report the findings of a posterior hip dislocation in a healthy boy in early adolescence caused by a ground level fall on grass with review of the literature. Closed reduction of the right hip was performed within 4 hours of the dislocation. A 6-week non-weight-bearing period was recommended before transitioning into a 2-week period of partial weight-bearing. At 12 weeks, our patient returned to sports and had negative radiographic and clinical findings of hip pathology throughout the follow-up period.

Background

Traumatic posterior hip dislocation is an uncommon injury in children, constituting less than 5% of paediatric dislocations. In a young child (less than 5 years), minor trauma such as a slip or fall from a low height may result in hip dislocation; whereas in an adolescent, a hip dislocation is usually caused by major trauma (eg, motor vehicle accident).1 In children less than 5 years of age, the dislocation can occur due to the soft pliable acetabulum and ligamentous laxity. As the skeleton progressively matures with age, and the surrounding ligaments thicken, a greater force is required to dislocate the hip joint. In this report, we present a case of hip dislocation from a low-velocity fall on grass in a healthy, young adolescent boy. Early diagnosis with urgent closed reduction ensured good outcome in our case. A high index of suspicion is necessary to achieve satisfactory reduction within 6 hours of dislocation since reduction after this period will greatly increase the risk of complications (eg, avascular necrosis (AVN) of the hip, skeletal deformities).

Case presentation

A boy in early adolescence was brought to the emergency department with severe pain in the right hip following a fall while running on grass. He was noted to be in a fetal position with restricted movement on examination. There was severe tenderness in the right groin area with noted internal rotation and adduction of the right lower extremity. The range of motion in the right hip was difficult to assess due to the patient’s discomfort and distress, but no neurovascular impairment was determined. The patient was guarding the testicular area making it difficult to examine and raise concerns for testicular torsion by Accident and Emergency staff.

The medical history of the patient revealed a healthy, well-developing child with occasional asthma episodes controlled by inhalers. There was no history of trauma, developemental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) or joint laxity.

Investigation

An X-ray of the pelvis was performed (figure 1) and showed a posterior dislocation of the right hip joint. The patient was brought to the operating room and closed reduction of the hip was performed under general anaesthesia (GA) within 4 hours of the dislocation using the Allis method very gently (figure 2). The fluoroscopic examination following the reduction confirmed a stable reduction of the right hip joint. Post-reduction stability of the right hip joint was also assessed and showed a stable hip at 100° of flexion and 20° of adduction. A detailed testicular examination after the reduction was additionally performed while under GA and excluded any testicular pathology. An above the knee skin traction was applied following the procedure and the patient was scheduled for an MRI of the right hip.

Figure 1

X-ray of the hips and pelvis performed on admission.

Figure 2

X-ray of the right hip performed immediately after the hip reduction in operating theatre under general anaesthesia.

The MRI report (figure 3) revealed concentric reduction of the right hip with normal anatomical positioning of the femoral head and a small separate bony fragment found posteriorly of the femoral head, which is consistent with a posterior acetabular wall fracture, and a diagnosis of a type 1 acetabular fracture was made according to the Thompson-Epstein classification. The MRI also accentuated the extensive soft-tissue oedema and a horizontally oriented partial tear of the proximal right piriformis muscle. The scan failed to display any evidence of underlying developmental abnormalities of the hip joint itself. The skin traction was removed following completion and reading of the MRI scan.

Figure 3

Post-reduction MRI of the right hip.

Outcome and follow-up

The patient was immobilised for 6 weeks following the reduction of the right hip. A repeat MRI was performed after this period of immobilisation and showed a properly healed fracture in the posterior acetabular wall. He was then allowed to partially weight-bear for 2 weeks before transitioning to full weight-bear. He safely returned to sports at 12 weeks postoperatively and denied any pain or complications. He was last seen in the office for his 1-year follow-up, and clinical examination at that time showed a stable and non-painful hip with full range of motion. The patient moved with his family to another town and was lost to follow-up. He was contacted to sign the consent form for publication and denied any problems with the hip joint.

Discussion

Hip dislocation often occurs with high-energy trauma since the hip joint is stabilised by surrounding thick, strong muscles and ligaments.1–3 There are two distinct mechanisms of injury in a posterior hip dislocation.4 One mechanism involves a significant fall that results in a flexed position of the femur subsequent to increased axial loading, whereas the other mechanism is from an injury that forces the hip into wide abduction.1 Secondly, the force that is applied to an abducted thigh, in a flexed and externally rotated hip, drives the femoral head out of the acetabulum.5

Prompt reduction is highly important given the risk of long-term complications if treatment is delayed. Post-traumatic AVN of the hip is the most common and devastating complication following paediatric hip fractures. Therefore, clinicians should assess for signs of osteonecrosis at all stages of recovery since its clinical manifestation may take weeks to months to present.6 These symptoms include new-onset anterior groin pain or referred ipsilateral knee pain, limb stiffness and decreased range of motion.6 Additionally, AVN of the hip is also related to the duration of dislocation (poorer prognosis is expected with delays in reduction beyond 6 hours), concomitant fracture and soft-tissue injury, advanced skeletal maturity or multiple traumas.5 7 With prompt reduction, the risk of long-term complications and AVN is greatly reduced.

In the treatment of traumatic hip dislocation, closed reduction is recommended through muscle relaxation under GA or sedation. Complete muscle relaxation helps to prevent devastating complication of iatrogenic epiphysial separation and should be applied to closed reduction attempts before any intervention is initiated.5 Concomitant intertrochanteric and femoral neck fractures could also be seen, but these fractures should be treated after reduction of the hip joint.5 Open reduction should be carried out on failure to achieve closed reduction. Post-reduction X-ray, CT scan and MRI should be done for assessment of potential fractures, loose intra-articular bony parts and damage to the soft tissue including muscles and sciatic nerve.

There is no consistency in the literature regarding the proper long-term management. No literature suggests when weight-bearing should be permitted. Furuya et al 8 proposed rest and immobilisation by skin traction with a 6-week period of non-weight-bearing as the treatment of choice, whereas Basaran et al 7 found that 4 weeks of immobilisation was sufficient in children under 10 years. Specific patient scenarios (eg, injury pattern/type, age, complications, postoperative MRI findings) can help guide whether 4 or 6 weeks is appropriate.7 8

Long-term management is important given the risk of AVN, growth disturbances and post-traumatic arthritis. Risk of AVN increases with age, time interval between injury and reduction, and severity of trauma; however, no correlation has been found with prolonged immobilisation postoperatively (eg, duration of non-weight-bearing, partial or none).7 8 Although there is no correlation between weight-bearing and AVN, non-weight-bearing can be effective in preventing collapse of the subchondral bone.9 Leg length discrepancy and angular deformities of the femoral neck also raise concerns when dealing with children, especially those under 12 years of age.7 In their study, Basaran et al and Vialle et al 7 10 report the development of coxa magna in one of six and seven of fourty-two children, respectively. It is important that these patients are followed in order to properly assess the hip joint for any pathological processes, specifically AVN. Vialle et al 10 recommend a 5-year radiographic follow-up in these patients. On average, the recommended follow-up for hip dislocations and fractures is 2 years, although follow-up is difficult when clinical symptoms improve and functional problems dissipate.10

Traumatic hip injuries have high morbidity.3 In our case, the situation was non-life-threatening due to the low-energy trauma. A detailed evaluation on emergency presentation, and a multidisciplinary approach and early diagnosis with rapid diagnostic imaging modalities could improve the outcome for such patients.

Learning points

  • Hip dislocation in teenagers caused by low-velocity trauma is a relatively rare finding and constitutes a true orthopaedic emergency.

  • Clinical presentation can mimic other emergent conditions such as testicular torsion.

  • Thorough evaluation and prompt reduction are recommended to avoid long-term complications.

  • Hip joint reduction should be always performed under general anaesthesia to avoid damage to important neurovascular structures.

  • Patients should be followed up until they reach skeletal maturity to prevent possible complications such as chondrolysis and avascular necrosis that may lead to early onset of osteoarthritis.

Ethics statements

Patient consent for publication

Footnotes

  • Contributors MK—study conception and design, manuscript draft, review and approval of the final version. KC—writing of the discussion and review of literature for treatment management, review of the final version and corresponding author. AS—study conception and design, review and approval of the final version.

  • Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.

  • Case reports provide a valuable learning resource for the scientific community and can indicate areas of interest for future research. They should not be used in isolation to guide treatment choices or public health policy.

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

References

Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer